VCAT: A Quick Guide for Renters & Owners

Navigating rental disputes in Victoria can be complex; however, understanding the role of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) can help both renters and rental providers manage issues more effectively.

VCAT's Role in Rental Disputes

VCAT serves as an independent tribunal that resolves disputes between renters and rental providers. Common issues include bond disagreements, property damage claims, and breaches of rental agreements. Importantly, VCAT considers factors like depreciation and fair wear and tear when assessing claims.

Depreciation and Fair Wear and Tear

Rental providers should note that they cannot claim the full replacement cost for items that have depreciated over time. For instance, carpets installed before 1 July 2019 have a lifespan of 10 years, depreciating by 10% annually. Therefore, a 20-year-old carpet would be considered to have no remaining value, and claims for its full replacement cost are unlikely to succeed at VCAT. Similarly, blinds and other fixtures are subject to depreciation, and claims should reflect their current value rather than the original cost.

Recent Developments in VCAT

VCAT has made significant progress in reducing its backlog of residential tenancy cases. As of June 2024, the number of pending cases dropped from approximately 21,500 to fewer than 4,000. The average duration for resolving a case in the Residential Tenancies List is now seven weeks, with bond and compensation matters seeing an 80% reduction in time from initiation to hearing. (Source - https://www.vcat.vic.gov.au/news/vcat-makes-significant-progress-residential-tenancy-backlog)

Upcoming Rental Reforms

This year, the Victorian government will introduce several reforms to enhance renter protections:

· Ban on No-Fault Evictions: Rental providers will no longer be able to evict renters without a valid reason.

· Extended Notice Periods: The notice period for rent will increase and notices to vacate will been extended from 60 to 90 days.

· Ban on Rental Bidding: All forms of rental bidding will be prohibited to ensure fair pricing.

· Establishment of Rental Dispute Resolution Victoria (RDRV): This new body will aim to resolve rental disputes more efficiently, reducing the need to escalate matters to VCAT.

Tips for Renters and Rental Providers

· Documentation: Maintain thorough records, including condition reports, photographs, and receipts, to support any claims or defences.

· Understanding Depreciation: Both parties should familiarise themselves with depreciation schedules to set realistic expectations regarding compensation for damages.

· Communication: Attempt to resolve disputes amicably before seeking formal resolution through VCAT or RDRV.

By staying informed about VCAT procedures and recent legislative changes, both renters and rental providers can better navigate disputes and uphold a fair rental environment in Victoria.

The Marshall White Property Management team is here to guide both renters and rental providers through their property journeys. Reach out to us for expert advice and hands-on support.

Image Source: Central Park Project https://www.marshallwhite.com.au/project/385-wattletree-road-malvern-east-vic-1512154/